10 Proven Reasons Why Brands Won’t Work With Influencers

Influencer marketing has become a powerhouse strategy for brands to connect with their target audiences authentically. However, not every influencer collaboration is a match made in marketing heaven. Brands carefully consider various factors before choosing to partner with influencers to ensure alignment, authenticity, and effectiveness. Today, we are going to delve into the 10 proven reasons why brands might not work with influencers.

10 reasons why brands won't work with influencers

Irrelevant Audience Demographics

Brands prioritize influencers whose audience demographics closely align with their target market. If the influencer’s audience doesn’t match the brand’s ideal consumer profile, the collaboration may not yield the desired results. This includes your top cities/countries, the age ranges of your followers, the percentage of female and male followers, and your page niche(s).

Low Engagement Rates

Engagement is key in influencer marketing. Brands shy away from influencers with low engagement rates since it indicates a lack of active interaction and interest from their audience, which brands see it as a potential red flag for the partnership. If your audience isn’t engaging with your posts as it is, they probably won’t engage with a sponsored post either. This is why building a community first is important before trying to work with brands!

Inconsistent Brand Image

Maintaining brand consistency is essential for brand campaigns. If an influencer’s personal brand image or content style contradicts or deviates from the brand’s values and image, it can lead to confusion among the audience and potential damage to the brand’s reputation. You ideally want to niche down when starting out in your journey, and then branch out to other niches. If you start posting anything and everything, both your followers and brands will be confused as to what your content pillars are.

Questionable Content Quality

Brands expect high-quality content that effectively showcases their products or services. If an influencer’s content doesn’t meet the brand’s standards in terms of aesthetics, messaging, or authenticity, it may deter the brand from collaborating. Of course, content with your phone is totally fine! Technology has come a long way since the early 2000s, and many creators are using their phones to create content with the right lighting and settings.

Over-Saturation of Partnerships

Influencers who engage in numerous brand partnerships risk overexposure, diluting the authenticity of their endorsements. Brands prefer influencers who maintain selective partnerships to ensure their message stands out amidst the influencer’s content. That’s why I wrote this blog post explaining why it’s okay to say no to brand collaborations.

Limited Creativity in Content Creation

Brands value influencers who can creatively integrate their products or services into engaging content. If an influencer lacks creativity or flexibility in content creation, brands may seek alternatives to ensure the campaign’s effectiveness. It’s important to have a mixture of posts, including videos, static posts, and carousel posts!

Risk of Negative Publicity

Influencers with a history of controversies or negative publicity can pose a significant risk to brands. Brands carefully evaluate influencers’ reputations and past behaviors to mitigate potential damage to their own brand image. If you’re truly passionate about a controversial topic, then be mentally prepared if a brand who disagrees with you does not want to work with you.

Budget Constraints

If a brand has a budget to work with, they will be selective with which influencers they want to work with since they want content in a cost-effective manner with the best ROI (return of investment) results. Sometimes your rates might be out of their budget, or they don’t have a budget at all to work with with. Unless you are willing to work for free, I suggest following up in the next quarter to see if the brand has new budget then.

Geographical Limitations

The geographical distribution of an influencer’s audience may not align with the brand’s target markets. Brands prioritize influencers who can reach their desired audience segments effectively, both locally and globally. Ideally, your top country should be at least 50% of your base country. Bonus Tip: If you are based in the U.S., almost every U.S.-based brands and social media marketing agency will want you to have at least 50% USA followers.

Conflicting Partnerships

Influencers with existing partnerships with direct competitors of the brand may present conflicts of interest. Brands prefer influencers who can provide exclusive endorsements to avoid any potential brand dilution or confusion among consumers. This is where exclusivity comes into play, and it’s a hefty fee that you can charge! Sometimes competing brands will reach out at the same time, so make sure you are asking for the full scope of work and understanding the contract terms.

Influencer collaborations can be powerful marketing tools when executed strategically. It’s a great source of income if you are consistently working with brands. However, brands will carefully evaluate various factors before deciding to partner with influencers to ensure mutual alignment, authenticity, and effectiveness in reaching their target audience. By understanding and addressing these top 10 reasons, I hope you are able to analyze your page and create content strategies that will attract brand campaigns! Let me know if you have any questions in the comments, and I’ll see you in the next post.

Leave a Reply